Fandom

Beyoncépedia

Why Don't You Love Me (Beyoncé song)

137pages on
this wiki
Add New Page
Comments0 Share
NoImage

"Why Don't You Love Me" is a song recorded by American singer Beyoncé for her third studio album, I Am... Sasha Fierce (2008). It was written by Knowles, Angela Beyincé, Solange Knowles and the Bama Boyz and produced by the Bama Boyz and Knowles. "Why Don't You Love Me" is an R&B and dance-pop song that is set in a retro style. According to its lyrics, Knowles questions her love interest about why he does not value her fabulousness. Its 1950s-styled music video was directed by Melina Matsoukas and Knowles under the alias Bee-Z, and it stars the latter as "B.B. Homemaker". Knowles pays homage to Bettie Page in the video, which critics universally commended for its 1950's style sets and costumes. They also complimented Knowles for her acting skills.

"Why Don't You Love Me" was well received by critics. It topped the United States Hot Dance Club Songs chart for one week in February 2010, a little over one year after the original release of I Am... Sasha Fierce. On August 27, 2010, the song was released as a single in the United Kingdom. It eventually charted at number 51 on the UK Singles Chart and at number 14 on its R&B Singles Chart. Although not being released elsewhere, "Why Don't You Love Me" garnered some attention in Australia, where it charted at number 73; it bubbled under the main charts of Belgium and reached number 44 on Slovakia Airplay Chart. In the US, it emerged as the nineteenth most played track in dance clubs in 2010. "Why Don't You Love Me" was a part of Knowles' set list for the 2011 Glastonbury Festival, the Revel Presents: Beyoncé Live revue and the Mrs Carter Show World Tour.

Development and production Edit

File:Solange Knowles at the Ruby Lounge.jpg

"Why Don't You Love Me" was written by Beyoncé Knowles, Solange Knowles, Angie Beyincé and produced as well as co-written by The Bama Boyz.[1] Jonathan Wells of Bama Boyz said that they decided to try something different from what they usually do, by mixing several genres for "Why Don't You Love Me".[2] The song's inspiration came from the time they spent in London at the end of Beyoncé Knowles' The Beyoncé Experience tour in promotion of her second studio album B'Day (2006). The writing and production of the song began in London and was finished stateside in early 2008.[1] They admitted that the song's structure was unusual, however they were happy that it ended up in the Knowles' hands.[1] After The Bama Boyz produced two tracks on Solange Knowles' second studio album Sol-Angel and the Hadley St. Dreams (2008), she asked them to put instrumentals together for her to write for her sister Beyoncé.[2]

The Bama Boyz almost intentionally left the instrumental for "Why Don't You Love Me" out, since they thought that the song did not sound like the tracks Beyoncé was recording for her upcoming album, at that particular time. However, Jesse Rankins explained that they later decided to put the instrumental for "Why Don't You Love Me" in the email because they knew that Solange likes weird records, but, they made sure to send it last.[2] Out of all the mainstream-inspired attempts The Bama Boyz sent to Solange, she eventually chose that last and most unexpected track and penned "Why Don't You Love Me".[1] Jonathan Wells commented: "When they heard Solange's demo, we were excited because that track was more our true sound than any of the others [sent], but we still kinda didn't believe Beyoncé would cut it...but we hoped!"[1]

Beyoncé came to Houston's Music World Studios for a recording session a few months after Solange had cut the demo.[2] Knowles invited The Bama Boyz into her session at the Houston's Music World Studios to listen to the early versions of I Am... Sasha Fierce. Unexpectedly, after Beyoncé played "Halo", "Why Don't You Love Me" came blasting through the speakers with Knowles singing the song. The Bama Boyz were thrilled that she recorded it and loved the song.[2] According to "Anti-Music", the song was nearly discarded twice; the first time was when EMI Music prepared a demo of the song to send to other artists without knowing that Knowles had already recorded the song, and the second came during the track selection of I Am... Sasha Fierce's tracklisting, where executives felt that the song did not fit in with the other records.[2]

CompositionEdit

"Why Don't You Love Me" is different from Knowles' previous dance-pop songs as it makes use of a retro style.[3] It is an upbeat track that draws from the genre of R&B.[4] The song also contains elements of up-tempo disco and funk music.[5][6] It consists of energetic tribal beats,[4] a drum loop, funky guitars and a bassline that was designed to make it a groovy and dance song. According to the lyrics of "Why Don't You Love Me", Knowles impersonates a woman who questions her love interest about the reason for which he does not value her fabulousness,[3] convincing him she's the best thing for him[7] as she sings: "Why don't you love me... when I make me so damn easy to love?... I got beauty... I got class... I got style and I got ass...".[4][8] The singer further tells her love interest that the decision not to choose her is "entirely foolish".[7]

Release and receptionEdit

Originally released as a pre-order bonus track on the deluxe edition of I Am... Sasha Fierce,[9] the song was later released as a new song on the platinum edition of the album,[10] and finally as a bonus track along with "Poison" and a remixed version of "Video Phone" featuring pop singer Lady Gaga on a digital EP titled I Am... Sasha Fierce – The Bonus Tracks.[11] On July 2, 2010, "Why Don't You Love Me" was digitally released in Germany[12] while its music video was included on a separate digital EP that went on sale the same date.[13] Two remixes of the song were later made available for download in the United Kingdom on August 29, 2009.[14]

Chris Ryan of MTV called "Why Don't You Love Me" a "dirty, disco-funk track."[5] Maura Johnston of The Village Voice called "Why Do You Love Me" "the stankface tour de force bonus track from I Am... Sasha Fierce in which Beyoncé reminds a dude that she's pretty much the greatest thing around and his choice to not be with her is an entirely foolish one."[7] She further praised the song, writing, "It's one of the best songs in her catalog, being as it is a four-minute summation of why she's one of pop's premier stylists right now; her vocals are equal parts pleading and snarling, the twitchy disco-funk beat gets hips shaking, and the declarations of confused self-love throughout can cause the listener to both root for her and realize that they've been in similar situations."[7] On The Village Voice 2010 year-end Pazz & Jop singles list, "Why Don't You Love Me" was ranked at number 549.[15]

Chart performance Edit

Although "Why Don't You Love Me" was not released as a single, it managed to top the US Billboard Hot Dance Club Play chart for the week of February 13, 2010.[16][17] It became Knowles' twelfth number-one hit on that chart and it was also the fifth consecutive song from I Am... Sasha Fierce to reach number one on the same chart.[18] On June 11, 2010, "Why Don't You Love Me" debuted at number 73 on the Australian Singles Chart.[19] However the following week, the song fell down to the position number 91,[20] before dropping out of the chart the following week.[21] "Why Don't You Love Me" stayed under the main charts in Belgium, reaching number 10 on the Flemish Ultratip chart.[22]

On August 14, 2010, "Why Don't You Love Me" debuted at number 142 on the UK Singles chart,[23] and it moved from number seventy-one to number 40 on the R&B chart.[24] After the digital release of remixes, the song rose to number 71 on the UK Singles chart,[25] becoming the ninth consecutive single off I Am... Sasha Fierce to peak within the top 75. It also moved from number 44 to number 25 on its R&B chart on September 11, 2010.[26] The following week, on September 18, 2010, "Why Don't You Love Me" moved up twenty places on the UK Singles to land at number 51[25] and ascended to number 14 on its R&B chart.[27]

Music videoEdit

Filming and concept Edit

The music video for the song was directed by long-time collaborator Melina Matsoukas and Knowles under the alias Bee-Z.[28][29] The video took two-three weeks of preparation and one day to film in Los Angeles on Mount Olympus.[30] The main set of the video was a house owned by a wealthy 95-year-old man who allowed Knowles and Matsoukas to use his house and collectible cars for the video shoot.[30] During an interview with USA Today on January 28, 2010, Knowles announced that she would be taking a break from her music career saying "to live life, to be inspired by things again".[31] She was then inspired to shoot a music video for the bonus track. In an interview with People magazine in August 2010, Knowles explained: "I came up with the concept for that video because lately I decided to take a break, and I’ve been home, being a wife. I figured it could be nice to give a little wink toward the things that I’ve been doing, so that’s why I’m a housewife in the video."[32] However, she explained that the video is "an exaggerated, over-the-top version" of what she was doing right then, just living her life, being a woman at home, relaxing and trying to enjoy her life other than performing and creating music.[32] For instance, dusting off her Grammys and getting under the hood of a car while wearing six-inch heels are not regular occurrences for Knowles.[32]

ReleaseEdit

"Why Don't You Love Me" is the ninth video to be lifted from Knowles' I Am... Sasha Fierce era.[33] On May 1, 2010, a forty-second clip starring Knowles as B.B. Homemaker, was posted on Vimeo. In the sneak peek, she is seen wearing an unbuttoned blue shirt with a pair of short denim shorts and a red handkerchief on her headwears while trying to fix a broken-car.[34] The complete video premiered on May 4, 2010, and it is nearly five minutes long.[29][35] The music video was officially released to iTunes Stores in the United States on May 18, 2010, two weeks after its original premiere.[36] In May 2010, the media reported that Knowles' decision to release one more video from her album I Am... Sasha Fierce just before Kelly Rowland released "Commander" was unfair on Rowland.[37][38] These claims would be denied by Rowland who said that despite the clip for "Why Don't You Love Me" airing several days before "Commander", the media was "making too much of a big deal of release schedules and trying to create a feud where it doesn't exist."[39] She also told Hip Hop Hollywood:

"We all came out at the same time and it really doesn't matter ... I think there's room for everybody ... There's B[eyoncé], there's Ciara putting something out and [Lady] GaGa putting something out, but, because we started out together, people are going to say things like that. But I really don't care, I love her [un]til our dying days and that's all that counts.[37]

Synopsis and analysisEdit

File:Beyoncé Why Don't You Love Me music video.png

The video begins with a tribute and sample of the opening credits of Leave It to Beaver which is overdubbed to introduce Knowles as "B.B. Homemaker" in a Daisy Dukes style outfit.[30] The song begins once she goes inside a house and brings along a board saying "Why Don't You Love Me".[35] Throughout the video, Knowles is seen crying, with mascara running down her cheeks while talking on the phone to her love interest, drinking a dry martini and smoking a cigarette. This projects an image of Beyoncé paying homage to Bettie Page just as she did in the music videos for "Telephone" and "Video Phone", where she collaborated with Lady Gaga.[40] In this scene, Knowles impersonates Betty Draper.[33] According to Melanie Bertoldi of Billboard magazine, Knowles contends to her deadbeat lover while sipping a cocktail and French-inhaling a cigarette in the music video. The fantasy-laden imagery hardly ends there though, as it is followed by shots of sequences of Beyoncé gardening, washing dishes, scrubbing floors, and baking cookies.[40] Rap-Up commented on what happens in the video, saying that she is also reading during some scenes, in which she sings "Keep my head in them books, I'm sharp..." In the middle of the video, Knowles dusts off her mantlepiece, which is covered by her 16 Grammy awards she earned when she was with Destiny's Child and after the debut of her solo career. The video closes on her falling to the floor after hanging up the phone and finishing her martini, and says the final word "...dumb!" in a scene in which she is dressed in a dominatrix-type outfit while holding a whip.[29]

ReceptionEdit

The music video received general acclaim from critics. Jon Caramanica of The New York Times described the video as one of Knowles' best and most vivid.[41] Brad Wete of Entertainment Weekly described Knowles as "one hot housewife in the [Why Don't You Love Me] video".[8] This was echoed by Tray Hova of Vibe magazine who stated that "Beyoncé makes a mighty fine housewife".[42] Jayson Rodriguez of MTV News said that she did her best impersonation of Betty Draper.[33] The Music Network complimented the production of the video while simultaneously making reference to Christina Aguilera and criticising the latter for her new video for her single "Not Myself Tonight", writing: "...housework has never looked so good ... Proving you don't have to wear bondage gear and a ball-gag to be sexy (hello Christina!), the [19]50s-style video sees the R&B queen [Knowles] getting dirty in a different way: dusting her Grammys, watering the plants and scrubbing the shower in vintage lingerie... She can come over to our house anytime."[43] Melanie Bertoldi of Billboard magazine commented on Knowles' "dominatrix costume" at the end to Rihanna's Rated R era. She finally complimented the music video by saying that "Beyoncé's shamelessly campy performance—complete with boatloads of running mascara—is generously refreshing."[40] Chris Ryan of MTV Buzzworthy noted that the video was "kind of a tour de force" and compared it with the one for "Telephone" (2010). He also noted that it showed "Beyoncé on the edge of a nervous breakdown."[5]

Amy Odell of New York magazine praised the video and noted that "the crazy twitchy behavior she exhibited in 'Telephone' returns to much delight, but with a wardrobe that's pure housewife instead of cold-blooded drag-queen murderer."[44] Odell also praised the playsuits in the video, which according to here were "a classier, more mature version of 'tards."[44] In another review, Odell concluded "It would be easy to credit the look of Beyoncé's new video to Lady Gaga's influence."[45] Francesca Stabile of The Village Voice gave a positive review for the video, writing, "The retro-glam outfits, the oversized martini glass, the rolling around on the bed sobbing with eye makeup running down her face... this is our favorite Bey[oncé] video ever. No one else can make doing household chores (dusting Grammys!) simultaneously look this good and this sad."[46] Gordon Smart of The Sun praised Knowles' "strong look" completed by lumberjack shirt, bandana and denim hotpants in the video further comparing it with Amy Winehouse's.[47] Daniel Kreps of Rolling Stone magazine described the video as a "Douglas Sirk film through the eyes of David LaChapelle" and noted that several scenes looked like Knowles was being photographed for Vogue magazine on the set of The Brady Bunch. He concluded that "If Beyoncé was lobbying for a temptress role on Mad Men, 'Why Don't You Love Me,'... would make the perfect audition reel."[48]

RecognitionEdit

Becky Bain of Idolator described Knowles as "adorable and funny" in the nostalgic, 60s-inspired video for "Why Don't You Love Me". She also said that her retro-style is "supercute" and charming.[49] On August 3, 2010, Bain claimed that "Why Don't You Love Me" is one of the videos that should have been nominated for Video of the Year at the 2010 MTV Video Music Awards,[50] and she later said on September 8, 2010, that the clip for "Why Don't You Love Me" should have been nominated instead that of "Video Phone", in the category for Best Female Video at the 2010 MTV Video Music Awards.[51] "Why Don't You Love Me" also made number nine in Rap-Up's Best Videos of 2010.[52] In February 2012, Kat George of VH1 placed the video at number one on her list of "The 6 Best Sets of Devastated Raccoon Eyes in Music Video History", writing, "Beyoncé wins best panda eyes on the strength of melodrama... and because she looks really hot in vintage style lingerie. Clearly tortured, Beyoncé's panda eyes are paired with martinis, cigarettes, and just the right amount of crazy to make the whole thing unbearably sexy."[53] In 2013, John Boone and Jennifer Cady of E! Online placed the video at number three on their list of Knowles' ten best music videos, writing, "It's like a trip back in time. Except with sexier outfits, which were definitely missing from the '60s. So good call, Beyoncé! You can even upgrade history!".[54] In January 2010, the video garnered a nomination in the category of Outstanding Music Video at the 42nd NAACP Image Award.[55]

Lawsuit Edit

Philip Markowitz, a neighbor of the man on whose property the video was filmed, filed a lawsuit on May 28, 2010, in Los Angeles seeking $25,000. He sued Knowles, the companies "Klener & Company" and "Bags and Boards", and Dina Ciccotello, for the video shoot for "Why Don't You Love Me".[56] Markowitz complained that during the morning, every time he tried leaving his house, the crew was blocking his driveway. Markowitz claims that he "missed several business calls while arguing calmly in his driveway". According to him: "[He] demanded compensation for the trespass on his property and the inconvenience and delay he had already suffered."[57] The case was later dismissed by a superior court judge in September.[58]

Live performancesEdit

File:Beyonce Why Don't You Love Me.jpg

Beyoncé performed "Why Don't You Love Me" live for the first time the 2011 Glastonbury Festival on June 26, 2011. During the performance she danced with her male backup dancers and the official video of the song was played on a screen behind them.[59] Later, in May 2012, Beyoncé performed a funky version of the song as a part of her revue show Revel Presents: Beyoncé Live in Atlantic City, New Jersey at Revel.[60][61][62] While reviewing the show, Ben Ratliff of The New York Times wrote: "Then she makes some of the most thorough and gold-plated declarations of self-worth ever rendered in pop. 'There’s nothing not to love about me,' she sang... without needing to make a joke out of it."[63] Maura Johnston of The Village Voice was also positive about the performance of the song, saying, "Live, she threw herself into the track, from tsk-tsk-tsk opening to impassioned ending; after that, the song's frenetic beat got transformed into an extended outro that showcased her band's prowess in such a convincing way, she took off her shoes to dance along with it."[7] "Why Don't You Love Me" was included in the set list of Beyoncé's The Mrs. Carter Show World Tour (2013-2014).[64]

The song was performed during Beyoncé and Jay-Z's co-headlining On the Run Tour (2014).[65] Throughout the performance of the song, Beyoncé stopped performing several times watching the crowd while fans were blowing her hair.[66] Rebecca Thomas of the MTV News felt that the performance of the song "seemed to reopen old wounds".[67] Kat Bein from the Miami New Times described the performance as one of the most dramatic moments of the concert further hailing it as "one of the rawest things we've ever seen at a stadium show".[66]

Use in visual media and Grace Potter's coverEdit

In her second commercial for HDTV manufacturer Vizio, Knowles is shown battling herself for a guy's attention.[68] The mini video was set to "Why Don't You Love Me" and it was directed by Jake Nava, who previously directed music videos for Knowles' "Crazy in Love" (2003) and "Single Ladies" (2008) amongst others.[69] Knowles explained the concept of the commercial to Rap-Up, "The concept today is basically someone's watching the television and I've decided to step in their living room and perform especially for them. The TV looks so wonderful, they're ignoring me so I'm stepping it up and I'm trying to perform harder and it doesn't matter, the TV is better."[69] The spot premiered on Thanksgiving Day on November 24, 2010. A writer of Rap-Up commented that Knowles "[brought] her alter ego Sasha Fierce back from the dead", and that she faces her "toughest competition yet—herself."[68]

In late April 2011, Grace Potter from the American rock band Grace Potter and the Nocturnals sang a rootsy acoustic rendition of "Why Don't You Love Me" along with strategic handclaps and drummer Matthew Burr's backbeat.[70] Potter said that choosing to cover "Why Don't You Love Me" was easy because she is "big-voiced". She elaborated: "As I was watching the video, I was watching for the visual candy. Then I slowly began falling in love with the song."[70] Jessica Letkemann of Billboard magazine complimented the cover, writing: "[the band] may usually rock with a 60s feel while Texas-born Beyoncé is a queen of R&B, but one thing the two women undoubtedly have in common is an amazing set of pipes."[70]

Formats and track listingsEdit

  • German Digital Single[12]
  1. "Why Don't You Love Me" – 3:37
  2. "Why Don't You Love Me" (Jump Smokers Club Remix) – 3:57
  • German Digital EP[13]
  1. "Why Don't You Love Me" – 3:37
  2. "Why Don't You Love Me" (Jump Smokers Club Remix) – 3:57
  3. "Why Don't You Love Me" (Video) – 4:50
  • UK Digital Remixes[14]
  1. "Why Don't You Love Me" (MK Ultras Remix – Radio Edit) – 3:34
  2. "Why Don't You Love Me" (Starsmith Remix – Radio Edit) – 3:33

PersonnelEdit

Credits are taken from I Am... Sasha FierceTemplate:'s liner notes.[71]

  • Vocals – Beyoncé Knowles
  • Producers and recorded by – Bama Boyz, Beyoncé Knowles
  • Vocal production – Beyoncé Knowles
  • Writers – Beyoncé Knowles, Solange Knowles, Angela Beyince, Eddie Smith III, Jesse Rankins and Jonathan Wells

Charts Edit

Template:SinglechartTemplate:SinglechartTemplate:SinglechartTemplate:SinglechartTemplate:SinglechartTemplate:SinglechartTemplate:Singlechart
Chart (2010) Peak
position
Brazil (Billboard) Hot 100 Airplay[72] 21
Germany (Deutsche Black Charts)[73] 4

Year-end chartsEdit

Chart (2010) Position
US Billboard Hot Dance Club Play Songs[74] 19

Release historyEdit

Release dates, record label and format details
Country Date Format Label
Germany[13] July 2, 2010 Digital single, Digital EP Sony Music Entertainment
United Kingdom[75] August 27, 2010 Digital Remix Single

See alsoEdit

Template:Wikipedia books

ReferencesEdit

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Template:Cite web
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Template:Cite web
  3. 3.0 3.1 Template:Cite web
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 Template:Cite web
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 Template:Cite web
  6. Template:Cite web
  7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 Template:Cite web
  8. 8.0 8.1 Template:Cite web
  9. Template:Cite web
  10. Template:Cite web
  11. Template:Cite web
  12. 12.0 12.1 Template:Cite web
  13. 13.0 13.1 13.2 Template:Cite web
  14. 14.0 14.1 Template:Cite web
  15. Template:Cite web
  16. Template:Cite web
  17. Template:Cite web
  18. Template:Cite news
  19. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named aus1
  20. Template:Cite web
  21. Template:Cite web
  22. Template:Cite web
  23. Template:Cite web
  24. Template:Cite web
  25. 25.0 25.1 Template:Cite web
  26. Template:Cite web
  27. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ukr.26b
  28. Template:Cite web
  29. 29.0 29.1 29.2 Template:Cite web
  30. 30.0 30.1 30.2 Template:Cite web
  31. Template:Cite web
  32. 32.0 32.1 32.2 Template:Cite web
  33. 33.0 33.1 33.2 Template:Cite web
  34. Template:Cite web
  35. 35.0 35.1 Template:Cite web
  36. Template:Cite web
  37. 37.0 37.1 Template:Cite web
  38. Template:Cite web
  39. Template:Cite web
  40. 40.0 40.1 40.2 Template:Cite web
  41. Template:Cite web
  42. Template:Cite web
  43. Template:Cite journal
  44. 44.0 44.1 Template:Cite web
  45. Template:Cite web
  46. Template:Cite web
  47. Template:Cite web
  48. Template:Cite web
  49. Template:Cite web
  50. Template:Cite web
  51. Template:Cite web
  52. Template:Cite web
  53. Template:Cite web
  54. Template:Cite web
  55. Template:Cite web
  56. Template:Cite web
  57. Template:Cite web
  58. Template:Cite web
  59. Template:Cite news
  60. Template:Cite web
  61. Template:Cite web
  62. Template:Cite web
  63. Template:Cite news
  64. Template:Cite web
  65. Template:Cite web
  66. 66.0 66.1 Template:Cite web
  67. Template:Cite web
  68. 68.0 68.1 Template:Cite web
  69. 69.0 69.1 Template:Cite web
  70. 70.0 70.1 70.2 Template:Cite web
  71. Beyoncé Knowles – I Am... Sasha Fierce (Platinum Edition) (Liner Notes). Columbia Records (2009).
  72. "Brazil Hot 100 Airplay" (in Portuguese). Billboard Brasil (Brazil: bpp) (2): 100. 2010-10-18.
  73. Template:Cite web
  74. Template:Cite web
  75. Template:Cite web

External linksEdit

Template:Beyoncé songs Template:Good article

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.